Survey uncovers financial integrity threatened by change
External pressures on manufacturers from mergers and acquisitions, organisational change and regulatory compliance are causing 'fault lines' in financial processes that are exposing businesses to potential fraud, mistakes and inefficiencies. According to new research into the financial practices of manufacturing organisations, the greater the level of change experienced by companies, the higher the chances of financial error and risk exposure.
Independent research commissioned by ACL Services across the UK, North America and Germany surveyed 33 manufacturing companies. It found that 58% of the companies surveyed had either merged, been acquired or undergone a departmental merger in the past 12 months.
Against this backdrop, key findings included:
Financial systems undermined by change - 82% of businesses have undergone some level of change in their financial analysis applications over the past 12 months and almost half of respondents (49%) believe that their financial systems have been undermined by operational change within the business
Struggling to control errors - One in three businesses are exposed to regular finance department errors and 58% are seeking to improve the effectiveness of financial transaction analysis
Finding a balance - 39% of respondents agree that finding a balance between optimal internal controls vs. over controlled systems that can't keep pace with the business is an ongoing struggle
Commenting on the survey results, Harald Will, President and CEO, ACL Services, said: "It appears that enterprise financial systems and processes within the manufacturing sector are buckling under the pressure of constant change. Even seemingly simple changes to business structures, such as the merger of a department or a move to a shared services centre, can involve massive financial consolidation and upheaval. Constant change equals greater risk and businesses need to have much tighter systems and monitoring in place to manage both."
The potential financial pitfalls brought about by change are already being felt by businesses. 17% of companies admitted to experiencing financial loss due to poor risk management, 4% had been asked to improve their processes by regulators and 8% had already been fined for deficient compliance controls. Perhaps as a response to this, one in three businesses stated that their approach to assessing risk had changed in the past 12 months.
Despite 58% of respondents agreeing that continuous auditing and monitoring of financial transactions across their organisation is an effective way to mitigate risk and improve accuracy, only 12% of businesses have such technology in place.
Harald Will added: "Small gaps and weaknesses create 'fault lines' that potentially destabilise an organisation's financial systems. And while businesses agree that continuous auditing is an effective strategy to mitigate these risks and bridge systems, they are still using ad hoc analysis in most cases. As they try to cope with the impact of change, they must invest in early warning systems to continuously monitor the fault lines for fraud, mistakes and inefficiencies that can cost millions in losses, as well as damage a company's reputation and value."
The ACL survey was undertaken by Loudhouse Research, an independent B2B research consultancy, in July 2007. The survey methodology involved Computer Assisted Telephone Interviewing (CATI) with a total of 33 senior finance professionals from large organisations in the UK, Germany and Unites States. Overall, 49% of respondents had turnovers over 500 million, 30% between 250 million and 500 million and 21% between 100-250 million.
About ACL Services Ltd.
ACL Services Ltd. is the leading global provider of Audit Analytics to
financial executives, compliance professionals, and auditors. Combining
market-leading data analysis software and professional services expertise,
ACL solutions give organizations confidence in the accuracy and integrity of
the transactions and the effectiveness of the internal controls underlying
increasingly complex business operations.
Since 1987, ACL's proven technology has enabled financial decision-makers to
assure controls compliance, reduce risk, detect fraud, minimize losses,
enhance profitability, and achieve fast payback. ACL delivers its solutions
in more than 130 countries through a global network of ACL offices and
channel partners. Our customers include 70 percent of the Fortune 500
companies and over two-thirds of the Global 500, as well as hundreds of
national, state, and local governments, and the Big Four public accounting